Felhasználónév: Jelszó:
Szerző
Topic neve: Why did i reject a question (stekkos)
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (CG)
541. hozzászólás - 2011.03.08. 04:00:22
I just had a question about the king and queen of Vegas in the 50's with a jazz act. I spent so much time trying to verify the answer that I didn't get the exact wording of the question and still never found a source to verify the claim.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (CG)
542. hozzászólás - 2011.03.09. 05:28:20
When was plywood invented?
200 AD
675 AD
1835 AD
3500 BC

I find multiple sites listing multiple different answers, but the only date that matches any of your choices is a simple wiki.answers page with no explanation or sources.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (CG)
543. hozzászólás - 2011.03.10. 05:28:26
Which of these was not a real, historical pirate?
Black Bart Roberts
Edward Teach
Calico Jack Rackam
Long John Silver


Odd one out questions are frowned upon. Rackam spelled wrong. Also, even Long John is a real historical literary pirate.
Pontszám: 5
much likedImLittleJon
Végzetúr poronty
395 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (CG)
544. hozzászólás - 2011.03.10. 18:13:43 (Válasz ChaoticGemini #543 hozzászólására.)
Idézet: ChaoticGemini - 2011.03.10. 05:28:26
Which of these was not a real, historical pirate?
Black Bart Roberts
Edward Teach
Calico Jack Rackam
Long John Silver

Odd one out questions are frowned upon.


I know Viridel frowned upon them, but I don't believe that has ever been stated as part of the guidelines. Please direct me to the link that states it.

Idézet: ChaoticGemini - 2011.03.10. 05:28:26
Rackam spelled wrong.


Not according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calico_Jack:
Rackham is often spelled as Rackam or Rackum in contemporary documentation
The sources I was looking stuff up in used the Rackam spelling, so that's what I used.

Idézet: ChaoticGemini - 2011.03.10. 05:28:26
Also, even Long John is a real historical literary pirate.


Please. Long John Silver is a fictional character. Treasure Island is a real, historical book. Long John Silver is neither real nor historical. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/real says
existing or occurring as fact; actual rather than imaginary, ideal, or fictitious
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/historical says
having once existed or lived in the real world, as opposed to being part of legend or fiction or as distinguished from religious belief



P.S. I do appreciate that you took the time to post with your reasoning, though. Thank you.
A hozzászólást ImLittleJon módosította 2011.03.10. 18:15:04-kor
Pontszám: 5
much likedSbartFérfi
Végzetúr poronty
879 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (stekkos)
545. hozzászólás - 2011.03.10. 21:33:10
From the Quiz: the aspects of evaluation (http://forum.doomlord.net/index.php/topic,14.0), first post:
"- Odd-one-out questions and questions about capitals are filtered. We have enough questions about capitals, thank you very much. Odd-one-out questions are always ambiguous, because any of the answers can be accepted from a certain perspective. Getting back to filtering, if your question is rejected, please don’t submit it again using spelling mistakes, because it will be rejected as well. Please accept that the system will not accept it. And please also note that any questions containing vulgar/offensive words are also rejected."
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (CG)
546. hozzászólás - 2011.03.10. 21:34:37 (Válasz ImLittleJon #544 hozzászólására.)
I am not going to dig through everything to find the exact link that points out the odd one out guideline. It has always been there, many of us have just looked the other way for some questions. The rules we were given as evaluators says, "Odd one out questions - We do not want this kind of questions, no matter what is the phrasing. I use the „Badly shaped question” explanation for these."
Pontszám: 5
averageMalystryx
Végzetúr poronty
25 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (stekkos)
547. hozzászólás - 2011.03.10. 23:27:25
I have a question for the evaluators...

this was my question:
how many hours are there in 4 days?

48.
72.
96.** obviously
120.

The question is valued as "Bad, incorrect question"!
According to evaluators your question is too easy or an arithmetic problem.

why was this question rejected for being to easy or an arithmatic problem when i just got the question How many hours there are in THREE days that DID get passed and was accepted?????

the question i got about how many hours there are in three days should ALSO be deleted then. Keep it straight guys, if one type of question is accepted, accept all of those types, don't reject some and pass others.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
548. hozzászólás - 2011.03.12. 03:46:31
Which of these organs cannot be transplanted?
Kidney
Heart
Brain
Lung

They actually are using partial brain transplants on mice. They believe it possible on humans with fetal brain slices. For adults, they believe we would have to overcome the ethical dilemmas of cloning to find a compatible donor organ.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
549. hozzászólás - 2011.03.12. 04:02:25
What year did Dr. Kevorkian face a 10 to 25 year jail term for assisting in the suicide of Thomas Youk?
2000
1999
1989
1990


Knowing the exact year with dates only one year apart is too specific.
Pontszám: 5
popularCruel01Férfi
Végzetúr poronty
714 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
550. hozzászólás - 2011.03.12. 05:24:54 (Válasz ChaoticGemini #548 hozzászólására.)
Idézet: ChaoticGemini - 2011.03.12. 03:46:31
Which of these organs cannot be transplanted?
Kidney
Heart
Brain
Lung

They actually are using partial brain transplants on mice. They believe it possible on humans with fetal brain slices. For adults, they believe we would have to overcome the ethical dilemmas of cloning to find a compatible donor organ.


That question was mine and I fully disagree with the rejection. Specially because I lost the right to another question!
Regarding the mice thing, I obviously referred to humans (Ok, it is not in the question, but I could have received my right to a question back and I would have included it at the end). Anyway, I found an article from the NY Times published in 82 (yes, that is right!!! - http://www.nytimes.com/1982/06/18/us/transplant-success-reported-with-part-of-a- mouse-s-brain.html) about a successful partial transplant. It seems 30 years is time enough to develop any progress with human transplant (which did not occur!!!).
Just because some people believe it might be possible one day does not mean it will.
The fact is that it is not possible today and the answer is absolutely correct.

Cruel.

P.S. As I have already stated previously, asking a question is not worth it. You lose your right to a question very easily and the SE you make is only twice for declining to ask. I will submit another one because it is my damn quest. Never again after that.
A hozzászólást Cruel01 módosította 2011.03.12. 05:26:14-kor
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
551. hozzászólás - 2011.03.19. 09:06:40
Which of the following is not a standard saxophone?
baritone
bass
soprano
tenor

They are all types of sax, to say which is not a standard is subjective to your musical exposure and special knowledge.
Pontszám: 5
much likedstekkos
Végzetúr poronty
1356 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (stekkos)
552. hozzászólás - 2011.03.19. 14:42:58
What do you call a group of dolphins swimming together?

Both school and pod can be accepted as correct
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
553. hozzászólás - 2011.03.23. 06:22:48
What is the deadliest parasite in the world?
Ring Worm
Malaria
Plasmodium
Common Cold

Only one choice is a parasite, but "deadliest" makes it a subjective question.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
554. hozzászólás - 2011.03.25. 08:58:16
What is Curious George?

Marked as spelling, because you may not realize that the popularity of the children's book has led to other things being called Curious George, so you just need to add a little more to the question so it's clear which one you are asking about.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
555. hozzászólás - 2011.03.25. 19:33:20
What was the magnitude of the Great East Japan Earthquake in 2011 according to the Japanese Government?
8.7
9.0 <--
8.9
9.2

From what I can read on the Japanese sites, it is reported as both 9.0 and 8.9. The cover of my newsweek that came today says 8.9. It would be best to treat this like dates and space the numbers apart a little more.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
556. hozzászólás - 2011.03.25. 19:40:17
“Wushi” contained what poison?
Arsenic
Strychnine
Nightshade
Snake venom

Since I assume you are not asking about Wushi in reference to a place, person or finger hold, I can't even find what it is, let alone what poison it contains.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (CG)
557. hozzászólás - 2011.03.30. 21:08:32
Which of these is the highest number?
The number of people who watched the 2011 Superbowl
The number of different 5-card poker hands (with no wild cards)
The diameter of the Earth in meters
The population of the UK as of 2011

I think expecting someone to know or look-up all the unrelated numbers in the brief quiz time is asking a bit too much.
Pontszám: 5
much likedImLittleJon
Végzetúr poronty
395 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (CG)
558. hozzászólás - 2011.03.30. 22:40:53 (Válasz ChaoticGemini #557 hozzászólására.)
Idézet: ChaoticGemini - 2011.03.30. 21:08:32
Which of these is the highest number?
The number of people who watched the 2011 Superbowl
The number of different 5-card poker hands (with no wild cards)
The diameter of the Earth in meters
The population of the UK as of 2011

I think expecting someone to know or look-up all the unrelated numbers in the brief quiz time is asking a bit too much.


I was able to look them all up in 64 seconds.
Pontszám: 5
much likedChaoticGeminiNő
Végzetúr poronty
583 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Why did i reject a question (ChaoticGemini)
559. hozzászólás - 2011.03.31. 19:18:01
What is the dog of Obelix?
Miraculix
Majestix
Falbala
Idefix

This depends on the language you read. The English name "Dogmatix" is not even listed as a choice. I don't recall either name in the German versions I first read, although that was many years ago.
Pontszám: 5
much likedstekkos
Végzetúr poronty
1356 hozzászólás
Profil megtekintése
Re: Why did i reject a question (stekkos)
560. hozzászólás - 2011.04.02. 10:32:31
Sloths spend on average __ precent of their life sleeping.

percent
Pontszám: 5
HKK - Zén minikiegészítő: Zén Legendái: A sötétség gyermekeiRésföld - a HKK legújabb kiegészítője